Jimmy Kimmel Live! Season 9 Simon Cowell, the first ‘Dancing with the Stars’ castoff, Gavin DeGraw Season 9, episode 124 Simon Cowell, the first ‘Dancing with the Stars’ castoff, Gavin DeGraw September 20, 2011 45 min Previous episode Dr. Phil McGraw, Jon ‘Bones’ Jones & Quinton ‘Rampage’ Jackson, Switchfoot Next episode Julie Bowen, Elisha Cuthbert, Pitbull